Most of us take American freedom of religion for granted.  It was not always this way.

In November 1769, a young Scottish-born preacher was locked in the jail at Culpeper County, Virginia.

His crime was preaching without a license from the government’s official church.  Someone burned sulfur beneath his cell window to smoke him out.  Someone else tried to poison him.  He kept preaching through the bars to the people gathered outside.

His name was James Ireland.  He had something every American has, whether we name it or not - faith.

Ireland survived.  History warns what happens when a government seizes full control of what its people believe:

Control what a people can publicly believe, and you control the people.

The question is not whether we have faith.  Everyone trusts something as ultimate - God, reason, conscience, or their tribe.  The questions are whether we are free to choose our beliefs, and what the common good gains when peaceful Americans live them out in community.

In America, the answer is still largely in our hands.  Are our fears pushing us toward isolation, double standards, and judgment of others?  Or are we choosing the power of love to serve a higher purpose, build healthy relationships, and invest in community?

Consider these four questions:

Q1 - MEANING

What Is Faith?

Faith is what we truly trust as ultimate.  It defines our purpose, how we process information, and what drives our decisions.

Everyone lives by faith - in God, multiple gods, a higher power, reason, or conscience.  Even people who say, “I believe in nothing,” still have a foundation for decisions - even when it is fluid by choice.

Faith shapes every feeling in our heart, thought in our mind, word we speak, and action we take - and our words and actions reveal what we truly believe.  There is always a gap between what we think we believe and how we actually live.  Life is more fulfilling when the gap is small.

Why We Live

Faith answers the deepest question any of us will ever ask:  What is my life for?  Our answer sets every priority, whether we have examined it or not.

Purpose in Action

James Ireland could have stayed out of jail by applying for a license or simply keeping quiet.  Instead, he chose to answer what he thought was a calling higher than any government permit.  So he preached, and went to jail for it.

That’s faith in action:  A purpose worth the cost.

How We Decide

Faith filters what we let in.  It decides whose testimony we trust, which facts we take seriously, and which ones we dismiss without full consideration.

This process works well when primarily driven by love - calm, wise discernment of facts, filtered through a strong foundation of courageous good character.  “Faith” fails as a standard when driven mainly by fear.

Decision in Action

When James Ireland was released, he did not leave Virginia, and he did not turn against America.  He kept preaching, and kept working peacefully to change what he believed was an unjust law.

That’s faith guiding how we decide:  Peaceful, persistent, and lived out.

The Boundary

As the first of Simple Liberty’s nine virtues, faith does not allow incitement to violence, true threats, or harming others.

Freedom of religion in America is an equal right for all citizens.  It must be lived out peacefully, without advocating violence or insurrection, and the rules must be the same for everyone.

Q2 - EVIDENCE

Why Does Faith Matter to a Free People?

Three witnesses agree:  Our Founders, history, and today’s facts.

Our Founders set the standard.  Many of the first settlers came to America because their governments tried to control what they could believe.  The Pilgrims fled England’s required state church, first to Holland in 1608, then aboard the Mayflower in 1620.  Catholics followed to Maryland, Quakers to Pennsylvania, and French Huguenots to South Carolina and New York.

Yet the temptation to control faith crossed the ocean with them.  Massachusetts banished Roger Williams in 1635, and he founded Rhode Island on religious liberty.  In 1660, Boston hanged Mary Dyer for defying its law banning Quakers.  And Virginia jailed James Ireland.

Our Founders learned the lesson and drew a clear line:  Government may not touch what a person believes, only what he does to harm others.  Jefferson’s Virginia Statute for Religious Freedom says government should step in only “when principles break out into overt acts against peace and good order.”

Our Founders also faced religiously justified violence.  In 1786, Tripoli’s ambassador told Jefferson and Adams that Islam and the Koran gave his nation the right and duty to make war on all who rejected it.  As president, Jefferson answered with the U.S. Navy in the First Barbary War (1801-1805) - confronting violence with force, while protecting peaceful belief at home.

History confirms different faiths can thrive together.  John Leland, a Baptist preacher, fought Virginia’s licensing of religion and argued that government should protect the Jew, the Turk, the pagan, and the Christian alike.  His ally was James Madison, raised Anglican.  Their faiths differed; their goal did not.  Virginia’s Statute for Religious Freedom became law in 1786, and the First Amendment followed in 1791.

Today’s facts also reinforce the cost of religious persecution.  The U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom, an independent, bipartisan federal body created by Congress, reviewed 29 countries in its 2026 report and recommended 18 for its worst designation.  Three of the largest:

At home, antisemitism leads the list.  Jewish Americans are about 2 percent of the population.  Yet according to FBI data, anti-Jewish hate crimes were nearly 70 percent of all religion-based hate crimes in 2024 - 1,938 incidents, the most the FBI has recorded since it began counting in 1991.

The Anti-Defamation League’s 2025 Audit recorded 6,274 antisemitic incidents - about 17 a day - including a record 203 assaults and three deaths.

Peaceful belief is protected in America.  Assaulting, threatening, or harassing a neighbor because of his faith is not.

Q3 - IMPACT

What Is the Impact of Freedom in Faith?

Consider it from your own seat.  Do you want freedom of thought?  Do you want to choose God, multiple gods, a generic higher power, or no God at all - without penalty, discrimination, or abuse?

Then that freedom carries a price:  Your neighbor gets the same freedom, even when he chooses differently. 

Respectfully agree to disagree.  America does not need everyone to agree on everything.  We are strongest when we focus on what we share - and we share more than the media and ruling class tell us.  Nearly every American wants to be treated with truth, integrity, and equal rights.  That is the heart of Simple Liberty’s three values and nine virtues. 

In 1790, George Washington wrote to the Hebrew Congregation in Newport, Rhode Island, that the government of the United States “gives to bigotry no sanction, to persecution no assistance,” and asks only that those under its protection live as good citizens.

Freedom to gather.  Faith is rarely lived alone.  We pour into a community of shared belief, and it pours back into us.

During COVID, that community was cut off for millions, and some restrictions went too far.  The Supreme Court ruled against limits on worship in New York in 2020 and in California in 2021.  

Many never came back:  By August 2022, nearly every church had reopened, yet the average church had only about 85 percent of its pre-pandemic attendance, and young adults pulled away most.  Faith restores a nation, and it grows best in community.

Impact in Action

When James Ireland’s congregation could not gather with him, they gathered outside his jail window.  About thirty Baptist preachers were jailed in Virginia between 1768 and 1770. 

Their peaceful persistence, with Leland’s advocacy and Madison’s leadership, helped produce the First Amendment - which still protects every faith, including faith in none.

Their faith did not end in a jail cell.  It multiplied into a freedom every American holds today.

A Word of Warning

When we stop examining our faith, something else fills the space.  People who answer only to their tribe and its information feed believe whatever the group promotes.  They miss dishonesty because they have chosen to trust the source blindly, in exchange for belonging. 

In America, the greatest threat to our freedom of thought is not that government controls our faith.  It’s citizens who voluntarily hand over control of their faith to others who are misguided or bullies.

Judeo-Christian values, shared by citizens of many faiths and none, are deeply woven into our Constitution and founding documents to provide Americans with the most free, fair, and stable government possible.  Sincere, peaceful faith is necessary to sustain our republic.

Q4 - SOLUTION

Why Is a Faith Worth Having Best for the Common Good?

Power can demand behavior.  It cannot force belief.

Regimes have tried the long way around: Force people to behave a certain way long enough, in the hope that behavior becomes habit and habit hardens into belief.  France, the Soviet Union, and Albania all tried.  In every case, faith outlasted the regime.

Dr. Larry Arnn said during his closing comments for an online Hillsdale College course titled Marxism, Socialism, and Communism:  “Having discarded nature and God as authority, what we’re left with is power.”

Unlike those totalitarian governments, America’s government gives the people the power to self-govern through our three branches of government and elections.

Our laws protect freedom of conscience, and they should.  But no nation’s laws can make a citizen truly believe in a higher power, or mandate how they live it out.  That is a right each individual is endowed with by our Creator.

America is a covenant nation - we live here by choice, not force:  We choose to be Americans.  We choose to disagree peacefully.  We choose to defend the same freedom for others.

James Ireland never held elected office.  Yet his faithfulness, and that of preachers like him, helped give every American the freedom to believe.

America doesn’t need everyone to share one faith.  It needs millions of citizens who examine theirs honestly and live it peacefully.  Here are three steps:

  1. Examine it yourself.  Start with the person in the mirror, and close the gap between what you think you believe and how you live:
  1. Live it peacefully, alongside others.  Invite someone of a different faith for coffee or a walk.  Ask sincere questions to learn, not to debate or convert them - or yourself.  Seek areas where your beliefs match.  End the conversation as friends.
  2. Defend freedom of faith for everyone.  Peacefully, calmly, and respectfully stand up for your neighbor’s freedom of conscience as firmly as for your own.  Speak up against antisemitism and against anyone targeted for living out their faith peacefully.

America will improve when more citizens live a faith that is loving, discerning, humble, and courageously serves the common good.  It is a journey, not a destination, and it starts with the person in the mirror.

Next, we explore Truth - what it is, and why a free people must hold on to it to stay free.

We can do this.

Simple Liberty unites everyday Americans to research the facts behind our nation’s biggest problems and develop solutions for the common good

…because politicians and billionaires won’t do it for us.

 Sources

Opening: James Ireland

Opening: Governments That Controlled Faith

Q1: Scripture and Quotations

Q2: Our Founders

Q2: Persecution Today

Q2: Antisemitism at Home

Q3: Freedom of Religion

Q4: Power vs. Faith

Image Source: Armmy Picca/Shutterstock.com